Middle Island, NY Homes For Sale | Rebecca Cramer Carr, Realtor | MLSLI.com - Long Island Real Estate
fill
fill
fill
Rebecca Cramer Carr, Licensed Real Estate Sales Person
Mobile Phone:
631-327-3280
Rebecca@RCRealtorLI.com
fill
fill
fill
fill
Rebecca Cramer Carr, Licensed Real Estate Sales Person
fill
Mobile Phone:
631-327-3280
Rebecca@
RCRealtorLI.com
fill
fill
fill
fill
fill
fill
fill
fill
fill
Email Alerts
fill
Buyer Information
fill
Seller Information
fill
Your Home's Value
fill
Community & School Info
fill
Real Estate Glossary
fill
fill
fill

Middle Island NY Real Estate & Commercial for Sale


Showing Homes Nearby Middle Island, NY
Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Ind/Land
MLS#:
3512176
Status:
Active
Courtesy: All Island Estates Realty Corp, 516-783-5600

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! HUGE 12.1 Acre Industrial Property For Sale!!! The Property Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, Strong Zoning, 1,000' Feet Of Frontage On Busy Edwards Avenue, Low Property Taxes, Huge Upside Potential, +++!!! Located Next Door To FedEx. Other Neighbors Include Costco, The Home Depot, Target, Walmart, Lowe's, Starbucks, Stop & Shop, Best Buy, CVS, ShopRite, Marshalls, Staples, McDonald's, Wendy's, Taco Bell, Burger King, Hobby Lobby, Fridays, Nike, Tanger Outlets, Panera, +++!!! The Property Is Currently Home To Long Island's Only Dirt Bike/ ATV Track!!! This Could Be Your Next Development Site/ Business Location!!!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
comm/resi
MLS#:
3500244
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Signature Premier Properties, 631-673-3900

PRIME CORNER MIXED USE COMM/RESI PROPERTY ON BUSY MONTAUK HWY.2 LEGAL STRUCTURES MAIN BLDG DELIVERED VACANT SECONDARY BLDG LEASE EXP 12/23. 20 ONSITE PARKING SPACES,IDEAL FOR MANY USES, CAN BE SOLD WITH 26 MONTAUK HWY WHICH WILL INCREASE LOT TO 1.4 ACRES, GREAT POTENTIAL DEVELOPMENT SITE(FRANCHISE,BANK, MEDICAL ETC....) . EXCELLENT VISIBILITY, HIGH VOLUME DRIVE BY TRAFFIC!! EXISTING BLDGS IN EXCELLENT CONDITION. OWNER RESERVES THE RIGHT TO REMOVE THE STAIN GLASS AND MAIN ROOM FIREPLACE MANTLE TBD.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Greenhouse
MLS#:
3551556
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Island Advantage Realty LLC, 631-351-6000

EXCELLENT and rare OPPORTUNITY to own a great Greenhouse/Farm. This unique property of approximately 1 acre is located in the heart of Bayport. Between its uniqueness LOCATION LOCATION!, right on the corner of Montauk Highway North (27A) and Sylvan Ave. Besides, having a house and a cabin, you can legally raise chickens, cultivate plants and sell eggs. The property comes with a house-type Cape with 4 Bedrooms, 2 Bathrooms, hot tub and a detached cottage with 1 bedroom and 1 bath, detached 44-car garage with a new roof, 16.000 SQF of Greenhouses. The heating system uses oil from multiple tanks, force air greenhouses, multi-zone heat in each of the 5 greenhouses. The house is a single-family residence with ongoing legal agricultural use. Store on property operated by the Owner and lastly, all the structures have their own COs. DO NOT MISS THIS OPPORTUNITY!!!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3518908
Status:
Active

CLC autorepair shop has been in business for 15 years

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Business Opportunities, Warehouse
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
1,875
Business Type:
Zoning:
Ind 1
MLS#:
3548174
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Classic Realty Partners Inc, 631-388-5255

Commercial Condo In MacArthur Business Complex. Prime Location On Main Road To Mac Arthur Airport.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
1,622
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3536426
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Realty Connect USA L I Inc, 631-881-5160

ATTENTION BUSINESS OWNERS! AN EXCEPTIONAL UNIQUE OPPORTUNITY AWAITS! This classic traditional office building is situated on over a 1/2 acre lot- Oblong Dimensions: (61' on Smithtown Blvd x 479 on east side) OFFERS PRIME commercial space with LIMITLESS POSSIBILITIES! While the size of this building is quite deceiving from the outside, inside there are multiple offices, 2 bathrooms, Nest thermostat, waiting area, break room, outside entrance from basement (also egress windows). In-ground Sprinklers. Ideal for various businesses, the expansive lot provides flexibility for customization and possible expansion. Embrace the potential of this well-located property, where entrepreneurial visions can flourish. Don't miss the chance to make your mark in this thriving commercial space! **OWNER FINANCING AVAILABLE IF QUALIFIED**

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3546001
Status:
Active
Courtesy: All Island Estates Realty Corp, 516-783-5600

Calling All Investors, Developers, End-Users & Entrepreneurs!!! Successful Corner Gas Station / Repair Shop + Convenience Store For Sale!!! The Property Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, Strong Zoning, Brand New Pumps, Brand New Double Walled Fiberglass Tanks, 2 Bay Repair Shop, 3 Strategically Placed Curb Cuts, (2) 9k Gallon Regular Tanks, 6k Gallon Premium Tank, 28 Parking Spaces, High 14' Ceilings, Security System, 3 Phase Power, All New LED Lighting, A/C, +++!!! The Property Is Located In The Heart Of Saint James On Lake Avenue 6 Blocks From The Saint James LIRR Station!!! The Property Has 106+ Feet Of Frontage On Busy Lake Avenue!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, USPS, Mercedes, Lexus, Acura, Kia, Toyota, Jeep-Dodge-Ram, Chevrolet, Mazda, TD Bank, King Kullen, 7-Eleven, Dunkin', Whole Foods, Costco, BP Gas, Lowe's, Trader Joe's, Macy's, +++!!! This Property Offers HUGE Upside Potential!!! This Could Be Your Next Development Site Or The Next Home For Your Business!!! This Property Can Be Purchased With 386 Lake Avenue For Only $2.988m!!! Income: 2 Bay Auto Repair: $48,000 Ann. Lease Exp.: 2026. Expenses: Taxes: $12,572 Ann.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Cent Bus
MLS#:
3545998
Status:
Active
Courtesy: All Island Estates Realty Corp, 516-783-5600

Calling All Investors, Developers, End-Users & Entrepreneurs!!! Corner Gas Station / Repair Shop + Convenience Store Package For Sale!!! The Properties Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, Strong Zoning, Brand New Pumps, Brand New Double Walled Fiberglass Tanks, 2 Bay Repair Shop, 3 Strategically Placed Curb Cuts, 66 Parking Spaces, High 14' Ceilings, Security Systems, 3 Phase Power, All New LED Lighting, A/C, +++!!! The Properties Are Located In The Heart Of Saint James On Lake Avenue Blocks From The Saint James LIRR Station!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, USPS, Mercedes, Lexus, Acura, Kia, Toyota, Jeep-Dodge-Ram, Chevrolet, Mazda, TD Bank, King Kullen, 7-Eleven, Dunkin', Whole Foods, Costco, BP Gas, Lowe's, Trader Joe's, Macy's, +++!!! These Properties Offers HUGE Upside Potential!!! These Could Be Your Next Development Sites Or The Next Homes For Your Business!!!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3546005
Status:
Active
Courtesy: All Island Estates Realty Corp, 516-783-5600

Calling All Investors, Developers, End-Users & Entrepreneurs!!! Corner Gas Station / Repair Shop + Convenience Store Package For Sale!!! The Properties Features Great Exposure, Excellent Signage, Strong Zoning, Brand New Pumps, Brand New Double Walled Fiberglass Tanks, 2 Bay Repair Shop, 3 Strategically Placed Curb Cuts, 66 Parking Spaces, High 14' Ceilings, Security Systems, 3 Phase Power, All New LED Lighting, A/C, +++!!! The Properties Are Located In The Heart Of Saint James On Lake Avenue Blocks From The Saint James LIRR Station!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, USPS, Mercedes, Lexus, Acura, Kia, Toyota, Jeep-Dodge-Ram, Chevrolet, Mazda, TD Bank, King Kullen, 7-Eleven, Dunkin', Whole Foods, Costco, BP Gas, Lowe's, Trader Joe's, Macy's, +++!!! These Properties Offers HUGE Upside Potential!!! These Could Be Your Next Development Sites Or The Next Homes For Your Business!!!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
10,890
Business Type:
Zoning:
-
MLS#:
3547921
Status:
Active
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Century 21 AA Realty, 516-826-8100

Mixed Use building containing 4,500 square feet commercial space on the ground floor which includes an Existing Auto Body Shop and Beauty Supply Store on the ground floor with multiple working areas and office space. The second floor consists of two one-bedroom updated apartments with lots of sunlight throughout, approximately, 1,630 +/- square feet of residential space on the second floor. Additional parking room/lot for the autobody part of the building. Contact agents for more information.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
mixed use
MLS#:
3487314
Status:
Active

Prime location in the heart of St. James. Well maintained structures: main building is zoned for mixed use, currently unoccupied, full basement, attic. Second structure is 2+ car garage and 2 additional storage pods. Private parking lot behind main building.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Retail, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
3,920
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3497221
Status:
Active
Courtesy: All Island Estates Realty Corp, 516-783-5600

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! 8.48 Cap 2 Unit Corner Retail Building In Historic Saint James For Sale!!! The Property Is Located In The Heart Of Saint James 2 Blocks From The Saint James LIRR Station!!! The Building Features Excellent Signage, Great Exposure, Strong Central Business Zoning, 8 Parking Spaces, High Ceilings, Private Driveway Parking, All New LED Lighting, CAC+++!!! The 3,920 Sqft. Corner Building Has 54+ Feet Of Frontage On Lake Avenue & 106+ Sqft. On 3rd Street!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, USPS, Mercedes, Lexus, Acura, Kia, Toyota, Jeep-Dodge-Ram, Chevrolet, Mazda, TD Bank, King Kullen, 7-Eleven, Dunkin', Whole Foods, Costco, BP Gas, Lowe's, Trader Joe's, Macy's, +++!!! This Property Offers HUGE Upside Potential!!! This Could Be Your Next Investment Property Or Home For Your Business!!! Income: Bike Shop (2,300 Sqft.): $57,600 Ann.; 3% Ann. Inc. Starting 7/1/26. Lease Exp. 6/30/28. Office / Storefront (1,620 Sqft.): $37,200 Ann. (Available) Total Gross Income: $94,800 Ann. Expenses: Gas: $0 Ann. (Tenant Pays) Electric: $0 Ann. (Tenant Pays) Water: $0 Ann. (Tenant Pays) Maintenance & Repairs: $1,500 Ann. Insurance: $5,000 Ann. Taxes: $20,578.86 Ann. Total Expenses: $27,078.86 Ann. Net Operating Income (NOI): $67,721.14 Ann. (Pro Forma 8.48 Cap!!!) , or

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
NB
MLS#:
3454124
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty, 516-759-6822

Investment opportunity with upside side development potential

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Office, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
996
Business Type:
Zoning:
WSI
MLS#:
3508436
Status:
Active

Professional Medical office in Smithtown. Professional Park End Corner unit 996 square feet, Reception Area, four offices with sinks and Handicap half bath, ample on site parking, ideal medical, legal, accountant, etc. 1st floor Ground Level, No steps, Central Air Conditioning & Heat Pump

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
18,000
Business Type:
Zoning:
Retail
MLS#:
3486736
Status:
Active
Courtesy: All Island Estates Realty Corp, 516-783-5600

Calling All Investors, Developers & End-Users!!! 12.02 Cap 8 Unit 18,000+ Sqft. Shopping Center With 2 National Tenants For Sale!!! The Property Is Located In The Heart Of Bohemia Minutes From The Oakdale LIRR Station!!! The Building Features Excellent Signage, Great Exposure, Strong Commercial Business Zoning, 48 Parking Spaces, High 14' Ceilings, All New LED Lighting, 3 Phase Power, CAC, +++!!! The Property Has 385+ Feet Of Frontage On Sunrise Hwy.!!! The Property Has A Daily Traffic Count Of 151,700+ Vehicles Per Day!!! Neighbors Include Starbucks, Hilton Hotels, Chase Bank, Toyota, Kia, Costco, The Home Depot, Target, Stop & Shop, Best Buy, Kohl's, CubeSmart Self Storage, Walgreens, CVS, Panera Bread, Marshall's, Valero, BP Gas, Dollar Tree, Burger King, Lidl, +++!!! This Property Offers HUGE Upside Potential!!! This Could Be Your Next Investment Property Or Home For Your Business!!! Income: Suite 1: T-Mobile (2,500 Sqft.): $79,350 Ann. Lease Exp.: 7/31/2024. Suite 1A: D & B Beer & Smoke (1, 990 Sqft.): $33,093.70 Ann. Lease Exp.: 9/30/2030. Suite 2 (3,990 Sqft.): $111,720 Ann. (Available) Suite 3: SalonCentric (3,150 Sqft.): $71,631 Ann.: Lease Exp.: 9/30/2023. Suite 4 (1,995 Sqft.): $55,860 Ann. (Available) Suite 5: Verizon Wireless (1,365 Sqft.): $65,779.35 Ann. Lease Exp.: 4/30/2025. Suite 6: Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (3,990 Sqft.): $63,600.60 Ann. Lease Exp.: 8/31/2032. Expenses: Gas: $5,400 Ann. Electric: $4,200 Ann. Water: $2,000 Ann. Trash: $3,180 Ann. Insurance: $8,200 Ann. Taxes: $50,790 Ann. Total Income: $481,034.65 Ann. Total Expenses: $73,770 Ann. Net Operating Income (NOI): $407,264.65 Ann. (Pro Forma 12.02 Cap!!!)

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Office, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Business
MLS#:
3544398
Status:
Active

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
1,127
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3497176
Status:
Active
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Comm of LI LLC, 631-858-2405

Priime, Storefront Property by a traffic lite is now for sale on a busy Main Street area of Smithtown , New York. This successful and profitable 20 year old Firearms, Fish & Tackle Business is generating over a million dollars in annual sales and net profits are approximately $300,000 a year. Open your own business and enjoy the similar financial security with the full basement and location by a prime traffic signal in the heart of Smithtown ! This property includes a large storefront with front and rear parking. The price of the listing does not reflect the price of the Inventory & business !This store can be delivered broom clean.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
5,614
Business Type:
Zoning:
Mixed Use
MLS#:
3522174
Status:
Active
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Coldwell Banker Commercial AMH, 877-221-4110

Prime Mixed-Use Building located on Rt 25 in the heart of Riverhead's Industrial Center. Ideal for user or investor. Building Consists of a Retail restaurant, 2 Warehouse bays, office area and outdoor storage area. Low Taxes!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
7,690
Business Type:
Zoning:
IC
MLS#:
3536971
Status:
Active
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Comm of LI LLC, 631-858-2405

Incredible Opportunity to purchase 8 Acre Investment + Redevelopment Site. This property consists of a total of 8 acres zoned Industrial C and is comprised of 6 Acres that are currently being sub-divided plus an additional 2 acres that contain a 7,690 SF Building occupied by The Hydrant Pet Hotel. Tenant has a ten- year triple net lease expiring on 8/31/2031 with 3% increases in rent per annum. Located in the Thriving Riverhead Area at the Crossroads Between the North Fork and The Hamptons! Perfect for Self Storage, Warehouse, Auto, Horse Boarding or Similar Use. Potential Incentives through the Suffolk County Industrial Development Agency.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
638
Business Type:
Zoning:
CB
MLS#:
3523226
Status:
Active
Courtesy: American Real Estate Assoc Inc, 631-862-6605

Conveniently Located Office Space With Plenty Of On-Site Parking Available For Sale In Marmil Plaza. This Second Floor Office Condominium Offers Elevator Access And Is Suitable For A Wide Range Of Businesses Or Professional Use. Monthly Maintenance Fees Are $170 Per Month.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
Business Type:
Zoning:
Commercial
MLS#:
3541983
Status:
Active

Downtown Riverhead Mixed Use Investment Opportunity. Brick Building Features 1st Floor Office/Retail With A 2nd Floor Apartment, Full Basement. With Adjacent Buildable Lot. Call For Details.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
13,000
Business Type:
Zoning:
Specialty
MLS#:
3429590
Status:
Active
Courtesy: First Hampton Int'l Realty LLC, 631-288-2122

Wealth Building Investment Opportunity! Investment Opportunity! 13000+/- sq ft, 100% occupied, Attractive current Return On Investment(ROI) with UPSIDE -Turn Key - Rare find in the subject area. Ideal for investor/end user or combination. Uses include but are not limited to; Specialty trade, contractor, warehouse, Flex, Storage, office, industrial, showroom, retail, professional, creative. Easy access to all, great demographics and large demand for this uses in the area. Great tenant-based, solid leases, and escalations.

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
9,248
Business Type:
Zoning:
VC VillCnt
MLS#:
3531193
Status:
Active

Calling ALL Investors! NEWLY-BUILT, MIXED-USE COMPLEX!, Ground Floor Opportunity featuring State of the Art Laundromat! THIS INVESTMENT IS TURN KEY! Upper Floor, 6 HIGH-END RESIDENTIAL Apartments, with PRIVATE ELEVATOR and their own Separate Utilities. Retail Space with separate entrance located in a Proven High Traffic Area! Ample parking for all, Plus Town parking on adjoining property. Fantastic Opportunity here!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
2,228
Business Type:
Zoning:
BUS PB
MLS#:
3540511
Status:
Active
Courtesy: Douglas Elliman Real Estate, 631-298-8000

Location Location Location!! Prime location in the heart of Riverhead, just a few blocks from the Peconic Bay Medical Center and Route 58 traffic circle. In the past it was a single-family home, now it is currently configured as a doctor's office. There is a full attic on the 3rd floor. Unfinished walk-out basement. Total of 9 parking spaces including a 2-car detached garage, and a handicap ramp. Take action today and make that call!

Type Sale:
Sale/Rent:
Type:
Mixed Use, Business Opportunities
Rent Per Sqft:
Apx Interior Sqft:
2,172
Business Type:
Zoning:
Comm/ res
MLS#:
3532570
Status:
Active
A broker reciprocity listing Courtesy: Corcoran, 631-288-6900

Just Listed! Excellent high-volume traffic location! Prime location in Riverhead close to Peconic Bay Medical Center and the Route 58 traffic circle. Currently set up as main floor Dental offices with a front waiting room with powder room, large reception area, 4 treatment rooms, lab area room and rear powder room. Other features include a full unfinished basement,12 parking spaces, an oversized detached two-car garage and handicap ramps. The second floor has a legal, income-producing, 672 SF one-bedroom/one bath apartment with a separate entrance. The building was fully renovated in 1995.

How may I help you?

Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent






We respect your privacy